May 1, 2007

Pre-election jitters, that is. Is a vote for independence the death knell of my great nation? Or will it release us from our cage?

I’m not qualified to say, which is why it scares me that I should have this decision bestowed upon me. I’m not a money man. I’m not a politician. I’m an academically-inclined nerd who works at a University. Why should I have to make this important decision regarding where our nation goes?

Given that I feel this way, it strikes me as really scary that most of the rest of the nation can also vote. I’ve tried to dig into the facts behind the propaganda pushed out by the political parties, but how many people actually do that? How many people really think about their vote beyond “Oh, I really like that McConnell chap” or “Fuck the English”? That independence is potentially fueled by hatred than levelheadedness scares me even more.

So it is with interest that I picked up the current issue of the Economist, to see what they had to say on the issue. I enjoy the Economist; it’s well written, and provides me with a hell of a lot of new information whenever I pick it up.

They say the jury is still out on whether Scotland could support itself, but they err on the side of caution. Summary? Labour’s numbers show that the Government spent £11.2billion more in Scotland than we raised in taxes. But these numbers don’t include revenue from North Sea oil. This is where previous SNP campaigns, by suggesting that our North Sea oil money would have made us rich, have fallen short in credibility: oil prices vary heavily with respect to time, oil reserves are running out (and in the meantime, becoming harder to extract), and perhaps most importantly we haven’t yet negotiated which parts of UK North Sea oil belong to England, and which to Scotland.

The Scottish Executive suggests that if all North Sea oil revenues were attributed to Scotland, we still fall 5% short. I’m not against increased taxation, as such, to make up the shortfall. But how angry will people be if the numbers really don’t add up, and the SNP fail to provide what they’ve promised? Does Scotland need an ugly burn of right-wing capitalism directly after independence? I’m inclined to think so. We might still be a bit too left-of-centre to succeed.

Do I want to believe in an independent Scotland? Yes, I most certainly do. Do I feel qualified to suggest that we can make it as an independent Scotland? Certainly not. Do I feel so inclined to support the underdog (ie, ourselves) that I should vote for the SNP this week? Almost certainly yes.


3 Responses to “Jitters.”

  1. Alasdair said

    The debate over whether or not we could ‘make it’ as an independent nation is, I think, largely academic. There is no way of knowing what’ll happen until it happens, c’est la vie!

    One way or another Scotland would survive, and it certainly wouldn’t become a Banana Republic as some suggest … we just don’t have the climate 🙄

    As I understand it there are international conventions and such like that govern who gets what and what territories belong to whom … does the international maritime convention not cover such things as sea territories? I don’t know 😳

    I’m not sure that independence is based on liking McConnel (or a. other) or the “fuck the English” mentality … I think there is much more confidence and and belief in our little country now than there has been in a looooong time.

    I think devolution has helped us solidify our own identity beyond “f***ing the English” … we are the Scots and we are proud, and why the hell not!

  2. Yes, it’s academic to an extent. But that suits me. At any rate, we have to analyse, otherwise we’re gambling on something very dangerous indeed.

    I’m unfamiliar with how the oil would be split up. But I’d assume that most conventions are in place to handle new discoveries, shipwrecks, etc, and not necessarily the internal bickering of two countries-to-be divying up a shared resource. I certainly don’t think it’s going to be a clear-cut case.

    Aside from that, lots of people do harbour a ‘fuck the English’ mentality, and many are unaware of how the Union came about in the first place. It scares me that the SNP gains this vote almost automatically. This vote is not an inconsiderable amount of the electorate.

    Ultimately, my overbearing point has to be that it scares me that I’m not capable of knowing who is the “best” candidate to vote for. This despite doing more research in my spare time than most people will have tried.

  3. […] Ontheoutsidelookingin feels unqualified to comment on the economic side of things — but will still vote SNP. Meanwhile, McGellie is sceptical of the use of data as a whole in the debate. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: